Juicer Patent Case in Europe: Kuvings vs Hurom – What Happened?

A major legal decision in the European juicer market has drawn attention from the home appliance industry.
The case between Hurom and Kuvings (NUC Electronics) has officially concluded with a significant ruling that may impact the future of juicer technology and competition.

 

 

Kuvings logo

 

Hurom logo

---

🧾 Case Overview

According to recent reports, the Unified Patent Court (UPC) in Paris ruled against Hurom in a patent infringement lawsuit filed against Kuvings.

• Court: Unified Patent Court (UPC), Paris Division
• Patent: EP 3 155 936
• Countries affected: Germany, France, Italy, Netherlands

👉 The court invalidated the patent and rejected all infringement claims.

---

🔍 What Was the Dispute About?

Hurom claimed that Kuvings products (including EVO820 models) infringed on its patented juicer technology, specifically related to a rotating brush mechanism inside the juicer.

Hurom requested:

• Sales bans in multiple European countries
• Injunction orders
• Financial damages

👉 However, Kuvings argued that:

• The technology already existed (prior art)
• The patent lacked originality

---

⚖️ Court Decision (Key Point)

The court ruled:

• The patent lacked inventive step (innovation)
• The technology was already disclosed in prior patents (China & Korea)
• A skilled person could easily replicate it

👉 Therefore:

• The patent was declared invalid in 4 countries
• No infringement by Kuvings

---

💡 Why This Case Matters

This ruling is important for several reasons:

1. Patent Strength is Critical

Not all patents are enforceable.
Even registered patents can be invalidated if they lack originality.

2. Prior Art is Powerful

If similar technology already exists, new patents may fail.

3. Impact on Juicer Market

• Increased competition in Europe
• Fewer legal barriers for manufacturers
• Potential price and innovation benefits for consumers

---

📊 Industry Implications

For the juicer and kitchen appliance market:

• Brands must focus on true innovation, not minor improvements
• Legal risks are high in global expansion
• European patent strategy is becoming more important

👉 Especially relevant for global brands expanding into EU markets

 

This content was created with the assistance of AI to improve efficiency and clarity.

 

Paris local division hands NUC victory in slow juicer battle with Hurom

 

휴롬, 유럽 특허소송서 쿠빙스에 완패…법원 "이미 알려진 기술" - PRESS9